Thank you, Helen Norton
Posted By:
Jeff Oster
Posted On: 2026-11-16T21:58:15Z
St. Mary v. Roy (case 25-581) was argued before the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) on 11/3/2026. The oral arguments are fascinating to listen to in this case. Written transcripts can be found here.
This case is another of the religious freedom cases brought by the Becket Fund to be argued before SCOTUS. SCOTUS, ever so receptive to take religious liberty cases, chose to hear the case which pits the rights of St. Mary Parish in Littleton, Colorado against the rights of LGBTQ students and families in the Colorado Universal Pre-kindergarten program (UPK). Helen Norton, JD acted as respondents counsel, arguing on behalf of Colorado. Her answers to questions from the Court were well crafted, delivered with authority and specific to the point of each question.
During oral arguments, Justice Kagan asked Ms. Norton about why Colorado has an exceptionally important interest in the uniform application of antidiscrimination law. Ms. Norton replied with an answer that made me proud to be a Coloradoen. She said:
"Yes, Your Honor, and especially so in the context of public funding, when a state is making decisions about how to spend the public's funds. And, again, it goes back to Colorado's interest, which is in equal opportunity, not some opportunity."
In 1896, in Plessy v. Ferguson, the Court found that racial segregation was reasonable if the facilities or services were 'separate but equal'. In Plessy, the court granted some opportunities but not all. The petitioners in St. Mary v. Roy seek special accommodations making them uniquely separate. The petitioners say that gay families could find other UPK services outside the Catholic UPK schools. Ms. Norton argues for something better: not just some opportunity, but equal opportunity.
Thank you Ms. Norton. Listening to you argue before SCOTUS was an inspiration.